For nearly RM 50k, should you go for the 2023 D74A Perodua Axia AV or the base Myvi 1.3 G with PSDA?

The base 1.3-litre Myvi is offered in two variants but for this comparison, we will look at the one that comes with PSDA, Perodua’s safety assist pack which starts from RM 48,500.

If you’re considering between the two variants since they are so closely priced together, we have put together a comparison that encompasses 5 aspects – looks, engine, ride, space, and features.

Looks – Axia appears more modern

Perhaps it’s recency bias since it’s just launched but in terms of styling, the all-new Axia appears better-looking than the Myvi.

Granted, Perodua isn’t exactly Pininfarina and its designs aren’t what you call head-turners but still, kudos to the team for designing an entry-level car that doesn’t look too awkward.

Also read: 2023 Perodua Axia (D74A) launched in Malaysia - 4 variants from RM 38.6k, which to choose?

Unlike its predecessor, the all-new Axia has a more conventional, low hatchback design. The all-new Axia has a sporty stance which feels more dynamic than the Myvi but then again, the latter is everywhere on the road so you might tune out on the finer details. Perhaps we might say the same over the all-new Axia eventually.

Also read: Perodua has smashed its 2022 targets of 247,800 units, and set new record for the highest yearly sales, ever

Around the side, the Axia has pronounced streaks and wider-looking wheelarches that make it both modern and sporty which adds a bit of a design character to the rather plain Myvi.

However, if there are some criticisms I would give to the Axia’s design, it would be in the back. To me, it’s a bit too plain and empty and this is where the Myvi gets a bit more credit in its design. Perhaps some Gear Up accessories could spruce things up a bit?

Also read: 2022 Perodua Myvi with Gear Up accessories looks like a permanently angry Pikachu

Engine – Myvi gives more power…

Instead of offering a turbocharged 1.0-litre engine from the Perodua Ativa or even a 1.2-litre WA-VE engine like the Indonesian Toyota Agya, the all-new Axia carries over the same naturally-aspirated (NA) 1.0-litre 1KR-VE 3-pot unit (68 PS/91 Nm) from its predecessor.

Also read: 2023 Toyota Agya debuts, Axia's Indonesian twin gets GR Sport variant

Axia's D-CVT shown

Just like the Myvi, all variants of the all-new Axia are only available with a D-CVT automatic transmission. According to Perodua’s engineers, the transmission on the Axia is similar to the Myvi though calibrated to suit the smaller engine.

Also read: Surprise! No MT option for 2023 Perodua Axia, but new 'old' Axia MT to continue - upgrades hinted

Yet, the thousand-ringgit-less base Myvi is powered by a larger and more powerful NA 1.3-litre 1NR-VE 4-cylinder that makes 95 PS and 121 Nm.

That on its own might be a big dealbreaker for those cross-shopping between the most expensive Axia and the cheapest Myvi. Why pay a little bit more for a fully-loaded entry-level car when one could get a more powerful car that is also the country’s best-seller?

Well, aside from claiming to be more fuel-efficient – Axia: 27.4 km/L, Myvi: 22.2 km/L – the Axia has one more advantage over the Myvi.

Ride - …But Axia is more comfortable

Myvi 1.5 AV shown

Yes, power is important and if everything is all just based on a game of Top Trumps, the base Myvi sounds like the more feasible option. But reality is more than just figures printed on paper (or a glossy trading card game).

Myvi 1.5 AV shown

Though we only reviewed the highest variant of the Myvi, we find the suspension set-up to be almost non-existent with zero comfort and the hatchback basically absorbs every bump on the road. To put it simply, the Myvi is uncomfortable.

Also read: Review: New 2022 Perodua Myvi is better than ever, but the Iriz still wins at one thing

Despite our first drive in the all-new Axia being short, we find that it feels better than not just its predecessor but also a lot more supple than the Myvi. It’s impressive how the DNGA platform belies the fact that the Axia is still an entry-level car and yet it drives better than a car that’s above its segment.

Also read: Review: First impression of D74A 2023 Perodua Axia - New gold standard for entry-level cars in Malaysia

Space – Myvi is in another segment

Dimensions-wise, the Myvi is still longer and larger than the all-new Axia which makes sense considering that the former is in a bigger segment than the latter. Still, the all-new Axia’s wheelbase is only 25 mm shorter than the Myvi.

X variant shown but split folding rear seats are not offered even on the AV variant

Perodua claims that the rear boot of the Axia can fit four suitcases easily just like the Myvi but while it looks spacious and practical, there are no split folding rear seats.

Instead, if you want to put a bicycle or something long in the rear of the Axia, you will have to compromise your rear occupants as only the whole bench can be folded down, even on the AV variant.

Meanwhile, the base Myvi comes with 60:40 rear folded seats so you can at least still put longer items in the rear without sacrificing your rear occupant to find another way back after a trip to Ikea.

Myvi 1.5 AV shown

The Myvi also has plenty of seating configurations which is one of the highlights of the facelift that also demonstrates its practicality. So for this round, the Myvi is a better choice which is a no-brainer considering both cars are in different segments altogether.

Also read: The 2022 Perodua Myvi facelift's seating configuration almost rivals City Hatchback's ULTRA Seats

Features – The real tiebreaker

The Axia AV comes fully loaded with safety and convenience features that might justify the seemingly large price tag. Only the AV variant comes with a 9-inch touchscreen infotainment screen, a 7-inch TFT multi-info display, and semi-leather seats.

Meanwhile, the base Myvi is as barebones as one can get in terms of features which includes a standard radio with USB (no Bluetooth), a basic LCD meter combination, and fabric seats.

Myvi 1.3 with PSDA shown

Both the Axia AV and the base Myvi offer PSDA but it’s a lot more comprehensive on the highest-spec Axia. Both models come with the following:

  • Advanced Safety Assist (ASA 3.0)
  • Lane Departure Warning (LDW) and Prevention
  • Auto High Beam (AHB)

However, the Axia AV adds a few more safety features than the Myvi 1.3 with PSDA including blind-spot monitors and rear cross-traffic alert (RCTA). The top-of-the-range Axia also comes with 6 airbags as opposed to the base Myvi’s 4 as well as front corner sensors and a reverse camera.

Conclusion

The price difference between the most basic Myvi with PSDA and the highest variant Axia is RM 1,000 and there’s no denying that you are getting a bigger car with a bigger engine for less in the Myvi.

However, in terms of features and comfort, the Axia AV seems to be a better deal even if it is RM 1,000 dearer. Some things on paper might make the Myvi seem to be a better choice but really it depends on the person’s needs and wants in a car.

Also read: D74A 2023 Perodua Axia launched in Malaysia, priced from RM 38.6k, 1.0L with D-CVT, 6 airbags

Numbers don’t necessarily give the final say in one’s decision be it price or power output but between the two, we would suggest going for the highest-spec Axia because you’re getting a lot more bang for just a grand more.

Oops... Something broke.
    Channel:
Follow our socials:
CY Foong

Writer

Traded advertising for a career that fits his passion for cars. Enjoys spotting cars during his free time and has a soft spot...

Hassle-free purchasing, get your next car fast!

users traded-in for dream car
Add your car

Upgrade

Perodua Axia

Related Used Car

Quality Cars Guaranteed

Fixed Price No Hidden Fees

5-Day Money-back Guarantee

1-Year Warranty

View More

Related Short Videos

Related Videos

Collecting The All-New 2023 Perodua Axia AV, No Need for ‘The King?’

2023 Perodua Axia 1.0 AV Review in Malaysia! Five Adults Plus Luggage on ONE Full Tank?

2020 Perodua Axia 1.0 Advance Review in Malaysia, Everyone Should Buy One!

2022 Perodua Myvi Facelift GearUp Body kit in Malaysia, Too Much is Just Right?

2022 Perodua Myvi Facelift vs Perodua Ativa Comparison Review in Malaysia, Which to Buy?

2022 Perodua Myvi Facelift D-CVT Review in Malaysia, the Untouchable KING

2022 Perodua Myvi Facelift 1.5 in Malaysia, Cheapest New Car With Adaptive Cruise Control!

2021 Perodua Ativa Vs Perodua Myvi Comparison Review in Malaysia, Which is A Better Buy?

Latest News

8% service tax: Car maintenance cost likely to go up in 2024, continuity of free service packages in doubt

Yesterday’s tabling of Budget 2024 proposed for the current service tax rate of 6 percent to be increased to 8 percent. The scope of the new service tax will also be expanded to include logistics, meaning that the cost to transport finished cars and automotive parts will be higher next year. Details on effective implementation date, or guidelines for car workshops are still lacking so we will have to wait for a separate announcement from Customs. The use of the term service tax is also causing a

Review: Chery Omoda 5 in Malaysia - Bang-for-buck hero does its best to exorcise ghosts of Chery's past

Something about rising tides and lifting boats paints the picture of the Chinese car industry, and among the pleathora of startup small boats rolling into the vast sea you have your vessels; built on the back of years of trial and error, no doubt buoyed with a full coffer. Of course, for a fair few companies, the motivation to chart new waters is to correct missteps of years prior. 奇瑞, or Chery to you and I, will know very well what the latter means. Yesteryear's QQ and A160 were a crack at the

Burning Proton X70 incident: Car now in Proton's possession, cause and findings to be updated after investigations

Proton has issued a statement in regards to a recent viral video, in which a Proton X70 caught fire. The particular vehicle is in the company's possession already. Further findings will be announced upon completion of investigation. Here is the statement in full, released on 13-October 2023: "Proton would like to issue a statement with regards to a video currently circulating depicting a thermal incident on a new Proton X70. We are aware of the incident and would like to thank concerned parties

Gentari wants to expand hydrogen supply biz, welcomes Budget 2024's recognition for EV and home solar services

Following today’s tabling of Budget 2024, Petronas’ green energy arm Gentari welcomes the recognition by Prime Minister Anwar when Gentari’s contribution to Malaysia was highlighted. Gentari CEO Sushil Purohit said, “Gentari is proud to be recognised in Budget 2024, a testament to our growing role in Malaysia’s clean energy ecosystem since our launch last year. We observe with great optimism the clean energy transition initiatives and incentives etched within Malaysia’s Budget 2024 and it is par

BMW Group Malaysia claims No.1 premium EV brand title for 2023, welcomes spending on charging facilities and TVET upskilling

BMW Group Malaysia has sold over 1,700 units of fully electric BMW i and MINI EV models in the first eight months of 2023, a sum which the company says positions it as the No.1 Premium EV provider in the country. In response to today’s tabling of Budget 2024, Managing Director Hans de Visser welcomes the extension of income tax relief for expenses on EV charging facilities. “Looking to the future, the need to accelerate the adoption of EVs as a greener and more efficient solution to transportati

Recommended Cars

PopularLatestUpdates
Hot
Mitsubishi

Mitsubishi Xpander

RM 99,980

View Model
Mercedes-Benz

Mercedes-Benz AMG GT 63

RM 2,088,888

View Model
Honda

Honda Civic Type R

RM 330,002 - 399,900

View Model
Upcoming
Volvo

Volvo EX30

TBC

View Model
Rolls Royce

Rolls Royce Spectre

RM 2,000,000

View Model

Comparison of Related Cars

Perodua Axia
View Now