Honda City vs Nissan Almera vs Toyota Vios: Which B-segment in Malaysia offers the best fuel economy?

Eric · Dec 17, 2020 01:46 PM

Honda City vs Nissan Almera vs Toyota Vios: Which B-segment in Malaysia offers the best fuel economy? 01

With claimed fuel consumption for all these newly-introduced B-segment sedans hovering below the 6-litre/100 km mark (2020 Toyota Vios: 5.8-litre/100 km, 2020 Honda City: 5.4-litre/100 km, 2020 Nissan Almera: 5.4-litre/100 km), which one of these non-national B-segment sedans will offer the best fuel consumption under real-world conditions?

Honda City vs Nissan Almera vs Toyota Vios: Which B-segment in Malaysia offers the best fuel economy? 02

Fuel Economy (Claimed, L/100 km)
Nissan Almera 5.4
Toyota Vios 5.8
Honda City 5.4

To find out, we pitted all three models through our WapCar instrumented tests, covering more than 100 km for each car. The route we tested the cars are similar, though at varying times of the day with different traffic conditions and drivers.

Honda City vs Nissan Almera vs Toyota Vios: Which B-segment in Malaysia offers the best fuel economy? 01

As part of our instrumented tests, we also subjected all three cars through a 0-100 km/h test.

Honda City vs Nissan Almera vs Toyota Vios: Which B-segment in Malaysia offers the best fuel economy? 02

While this may not be an exhaustive test, it is a reasonably realistic estimate of how each car will perform in real-world conditions.

Fuel Economy (As tested, L/100 km)
Nissan Almera 5.8
Toyota Vios 6.8
Honda City 7.2

UPDATE: We conducted another test on the Honda City and it returned 5.3-litre/100 km, so average fuel consumption figure is 6.3L/100km.

After putting them through our instrumented tests, the Honda City recorded an average fuel consumption of 7.2-litre/100 km, while the Vios was slightly better, coming in at 6.8-litre/100 km. While the City's result may seem poor, keep in mind that the car has less than 100 km on the odometer. Its fuel economy will improve over time.

The surprising winner here is the Nissan Almera, which managed to return an average fuel consumption figure of 5.8-litre/100 km – not too far from Nissan’s claimed figures.

Honda City vs Nissan Almera vs Toyota Vios: Which B-segment in Malaysia offers the best fuel economy? 03

So there you have it, three of the newest non-national B-segment sedans and their respective real-world fuel consumption figures and the Nissan Almera reigns supreme over its segment rivals.

Honda City vs Nissan Almera vs Toyota Vios: Which B-segment in Malaysia offers the best fuel economy? 04

We are currently collecting votes for the WapCar 2020 Car of the Year. Do drop by on 18-December to vote for your favourite car!

Eric

Editor

Started from the IT industry but somehow managed to find his way into the automotive industry. If he’s not gaming, he’s constantly tinkering with his daily/weekend car.

Trending Discussion

Comments

Up to 20% higher than average trade-in price

2020 Honda City 1.5L S

Upgrade

Add your car

Service powered by carsome

Latest Cars