Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV!

Sanjay · Dec 5, 2020 07:00 PM

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 01

When some of us brought home the 2020 Proton X50, one experience united us all: neighbours coming out of their homes to kepoh.

They can't believe it! The long-awaited, much-discussed B-segment SUV is right in front of them, and in the range-topping Flagship variant (RM 103,300 - SST-free price until 31-Dec 2020) no less.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 02

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Amidst all the hullaballoo one neighbour quipped: "It's like seeing a celebrity!" Which, to be fair, isn't too far-fetched: there's tons of content out there which would give prime Michael Jackson a run for his money. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 01

Being in the spotlight and all that is nice, but does the 'hypebeast' hold up well in our tried-and-tested, detailed-to-the-milimeter tests? Grab a drink and some snacks - this is what you'll find out today. 

Exterior - You're going to attract attention

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 02

There's no denying that this is a head-turner. Across our test route, covering small suburbs, the Kuala Lumpur city centre and open highways, people looked at us.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 03

We can also attest to how a couple of delivery riders gave their thumbs up, and some people - driving cars more expensive than this - stole a glance here and there.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 04

It DOES look angry.

The bad pickup line "you look cute when you're angry" applies to the X50, but mind you there's nothing bad about its design.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 05

Citric Orange and black roof? Yes please

With its sharp creases and lines, chunky 18-inch wheels as well as full LED head and tail lights all fit into a tightly-proportioned body, it doesn't necessarily need shouty colours to pop.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 06

Still, we're glad it's got those (and subtler choices too), but colour is merely the most obvious thing we can mention about the X50's eye-catching exterior.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 07

Clockwise left to right: Faux carbon-fibre pattern on the front lip, functional air curtains, real quad-tailpipes with faux carbon-fibre diffuser and standard spoiler.

It'd be shame if we were to just gloss over the details that truly set the X50 apart from much more expensive cars, let alone similarly-priced competitors. Kudos to Proton for keeping the carbon-fibre-look on the front lip and rear diffuser, breaking up the otherwise uninspiring trope of plain black cladding on SUVs (looking at you, Subaru XV).

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 08

The LED daytime running lights (DRLs) double up as signal lights - a common feature on Mercedes-Benz and Audi cars, but not for RM 100k ones

There's also functional air curtains in front and of course, quad-tailpipes behind. The 2020 Honda HR-V's fake vents pale in comparison, and on B-segment sedans like the 2020 Nissan Almera and 2020 Honda City, you don't even get a nice exhaust tip.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 09

No complaints on the looks department - heck, we'll even let the 'baby Evoque' comment slide.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 10

It's great that good build quality backs up its sharp looks. Panel gaps are reasonably tight - deviating no more than 1 milimeter from each side, and paint thickness hovers at around 120 micrometers. 

Interior - Looks good but could be better

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 11

Open the door and you're greeted with a very pretty interior. If aesthetics were the only metrics measured, the review would've ended (very positively) here. But that's not how the world works, so read on.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 12

'Enveloping Cockpit': The interior is supposed to mimic a jet's cockpit.

The dual-tone red-and-black interior upholstery (available only on the Flagship and Premium variants) works well with the cabin's styling cues. A fast-talking salesperson can easily win you over if you don't take the time to carefully observe the cabin's little foibles.

We're no salespeople, so we'll take you through them one by one.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 13

All map lights and reading lights are reasonably-bright LEDs. Good detail.

Before we go into that, let me set things straight a bit - there's a marked difference between build quality and build material. One is about how well put-together something is, and the latter is about what its made of. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 14

7-inch full-LCD instrument cluster tells a ton of information, including navigation and ADAS functions. Seen here in 'Normal' drive mode.

Inside the X50, quality is solid. Buttons on the centre console and steering wheel provide satisfying tactile feedback not unlike most Japanese cars. The dials and knobs look and feel great too. You know how some people like pressing panels just to see if they're 'tough'? We did that too, and nothing creaks or squeaks unnecessarily. Good stuff.

So, don't worry if you have curious kids. It'll hold up to their 'tests' just fine, but maybe keep them away from the door handles...

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 15

These buttons and knobs feel great. Those are card holder slots on the bottom left photo.

Which is where our main gripe with the interior lies. It's a missed opportunity not having the door handles made out of metal. The current plastic ones feel flimsy, make a hollow sound when you use them, and simply feel like they'll snap in half in a few years.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 16

Looks tough, but doesn't feel so.

There's copious use of hard plastic on certain touchpoints, like the centre console and lower-half of the dashboard. The upper-half of the dashboard and door cards are made out of soft-touch plastic. Quality is fairly middling, but it's forgiveable when you consider cars in the RM 80k - RM 100k price range don't even get soft-touch plastics anywhere in the interior.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 17

Meanwhile, the leather seats on the X50 aren't very supple. They aren't very 'slideable' too, and can feel like they're sticking on your clothes or skin a bit too tightly. Support is a whole seperate issue, more on that below.

We know it's priced very differently but if pinpoint-premiumness is something you absolutely must-have, look towards the Mazda CX-3.

Interior - so-so infotainment

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 18

Navigation is via AMAP.

Putting aside the fact that it lacks Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, the 10.25-inch touchscreen infotainment system works rather well. It's smooth, the screen itself is clear and bright enough and the 'Hi Proton' voice command is quite responsive. Too bad it still doesn't support Bahasa Malaysia.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 19

Propping my phone here to run Maps/Waze really takes the edge off the space-age interior. Not to mention accidentally hitting the climate control buttons.

To no-one's surprise, QD Link (phone mirroring function) is still annoying and not at all a viable option to Auto or CarPlay, so we hardly used it. AMAP is...average, but there isn't Google Maps/Waze-level functions such as roadblock alerts and so on.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 20

You're also able to adjust minor settings through the infotainment screen, such as instrument cluster theme (like sticking the Sport mode's red theme while on Eco mode) and alarm type (horn and lights or just lights). There's equaliser adjustments too, but that doesn't really help the subpar audio quality.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 21

Tweeter housings have great detail on them.

Sound quality through the 6 speakers (music played through Bluetooth) is just serviceable. The equaliser adjustments seem like they don't do anything, and music certainly lacks bass and clarity. Overall, it's not the absolute worst but definitely miles away from being the best.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 22

One way the X50 claws back points is in the steering controls for the infotainment. It's simple to use and we really like the 'mute to pause' function. It may seem like a no-brainer thing to include but it's handy when you have to pause your music instead of letting it run in the background.

Interior - Good visibility but not the most practical

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 23

360-degree camera could be sharper, but still perfectly useable even at night.

Visibility is fantastic. You get the coveted 'SUV driving position', all high and mighty, yet those moving up from lower-slung, smaller cars (say a Toyota Vios or Perodua Myvi) won't find it intimidating to drive and park. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 24

Quite a lot of gap there. Electrical seat adjustment is only for the driver.

Dig further though and you'll find ergonomics needs plenty of work. The seats are let down by short bases, which means a lack of thigh support. If you're taller or prefer the correct driving position, your knees will feel dull and your thighs will feel tired during and after long drives.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 25

That said, legroom for the rear seats are quite good (3 tennis balls) for a 175 cm adult. Headroom is only about 1 tennis ball. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 26

To those caring for loved ones with mobility issues, note that the rear doors open at a relatively tight angle. Combined with the thick wheelarches, this could make entering and exiting the vehicle a slight challenge, especially if said persons are wheelchair-bound. The HR-V and XV are better in this specific case.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 27

Our review unit wasn't equipped with the optional powered tailgate (part of the RM 3,300 Utility or RM 3,500 Urban accesories package).

The tailgate is a little heavy and comes with no grab handle - just a boot release button. Not very practical as your hand can easily slip. Doubly annoying when you don't manage to close it correctly the first time.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 28

There's 60:40 split-folding rear seats, but no more space beneath the cover - that's where the space-saver spare tyre sits.

For those with large families, think twice before going for the X50 - especially if this'll be your only car. All 8 cupholders fail our big bottle test, and the bootspace is the smallest in its class at 330 litres - easily filled up by one stroller and a couple of luggage bags. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 29

The gear selector panel and cubby spots don't light up. Counter-intuitive at night, especially when you're trying to find the power socket or USB port.

Other than that, the glove box is small and most cubby spaces are only big enough for an RM 1 mineral water bottle and some loose items at most.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 30

When it comes to utilising cabin space, there is still much Geely/Proton can learn from the Japanese. For instance, Honda's 'Man Maximum/Machine Minimum' philosophy shines in making their cars' interior class-leadingly practical - and the HR-V is a shining example with its expansive two-tiered centre console and easy-to-reach controls.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 31

Small storage cubby below the rear air-cond vents is a nice, practical touch; space underneath the centre armrest is just nice for a phone and wallet.

Driving performance - Proton's still got it

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 32

There's been concerns about its turbocharged three-cylinder and 7-speed dual-clutch transmission (DCT) combo, with most naysayers usually bringing up the uninformed opinion that three-pot engines aren't powerful enough.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 33

But it's clear that 177 PS and 255 Nm is more than enough for the average driver. Though we got a 0-100 km/h time of 8.6 seconds (nearly a second off Proton's claimed 7.9 seconds), in the real world it's the 60 - 90 km/h acceleration that matters more. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 34

Move over, Perodua Myvi. The new highway king is here.

In that respect, the X50 excels. Acceleration is gentle and linear (it won't pin your head to the headrest when you gun it) and even in Eco mode overtaking is a breeze, and better still in Sport mode. 

There more than enough grunt for 99% of Malaysians. Yes to some of you Genting kakis, this one will have no problems.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 35

The instrument cluster in Sport mode.

Sport mode here isn't going to give you pops and bangs, it just changes the transmission mapping to hold the gears longer. Don't leave it there - the car gets way too jumpy and aggressive in lower speeds.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 36

Achieving supple ride on 18-inch wheels is quite a feat, but Proton's ride and handling recipe here has done just that, ironing out pockmarked roads very well - something we think owes a lot to the good Continental UC6 tyres. Due to the soft suspension also, the X50 feels a little floaty going into corners at relatively higher speeds. This isn't too much of a concern as the car handles decently otherwise.

That said, the brakes could be improved a bit more as the modulation is a little vague. You feel as if they aren't doing anything for a while, then it suddenly catches on.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 37

Steering feel however, is great. The electronic power steering (EPS) is not featherlight as it is on the Almera, but that's a good thing because it doesn't leave you guessing where the front wheels are pointing at. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 38

For 99% of buyers, how it drives is already more than good enough. If you're looking for a car to "touge bro!" or rip through corners, boy are you lost.

Ride Comfort - very good as a family cruiser

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 39

Its comfortable ride belies its sporty exterior. It certainly isn't crashy when you meet a speedbump a little bit faster than expected, and it'll make short work of small potholes and puddles.

To put it in another way: babies can have a good sleep.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 40

Soundproofing in the front fenders.

The thick soundproofing insulates the cabin quite well. Across the board, it's better than the HR-V. Here's how the X50 did:

2020 Proton X50 NVH test
Speed Cabin noise
Idle (air-cond off) 42 dB
Idle (air-cond on) 45 dB
60 km/h 62 dB
90 km/h 65 dB
110 km/h 68 dB

It must be mentioned though that wind noise is quite apparent, especially when driving at highway speeds: you can hear whistling that gets louder the faster you drive. Perhaps additional strakes by the side mirrors and door visors could help rectify that.

ADAS - works just as intended

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 41

Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) is without steering assist. It also has stop-and-go functionality.

New to the Proton X50 is Intelligent Cruise Control (ICC), part of the Level 2 autonomous driving systems the car has. ICC works with lane centring assist (steering assist) to help keep the car in its lane. The system works from a standstill to 150 km/h and works when entering corners too.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 42

The system works nearly flawlessly - no sudden braking when a car cuts into the lane in front (unlike the 2020 Toyota Camry we tested) and it's easy to activate/deactivate. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 43

The Blind Spot Monitor (BSM) isn't obnoxiously noisy. It also looks like Volvo's!

One concern is during turns though. Sometimes it doesn't discern the silver highway railings very well, and the car will try to steer into it. Remember that ADAS is only 'assistance'. The onus is then, as always, on you to make sure you're driving safely.

Fuel efficiency - unfortunately, it's a guzzler

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 44

The car's trip computer can be slightly inaccurate sometimes.

We averaged 10.2 litres/100 km on urban roads with a mix of heavy traffic and smooth highways - driven at normal speeds. It's usual for turbocharged engines to return so-so fuel economy, but to not do any better than the 3.0-litre, turbocharged straight-six 2020 Toyota GR Supra is a bit much. 

For comparison, the HR-V RS returns 7 litres/100 km

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 45

Part of this has to do with the car's weight too. At 1,370 kg (HR-V RS is 1,290 kg), the X50 Flagship is a little on the heavy side so the engine has to work harder to move the car. The numbers should improve with more highway driving.

Conclusion - Still good value for money

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 46

When all's said and done, the fact remains that the X50 is a good car - but not nearly as perfect as the hype would lead you on to believe.

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 47

But you have to be concious about what you really want from a car before you plonk the deposit for one of these, 6-month waiting list notwithstanding. It's not made for big families, it has spotty ergonomics, and it's certainly not the most economical. 

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 48

For RM 103,300 (SST-free prices until 31-Dec 2020) though, it's a damn good deal considering you're getting best-in-class features, adequate safety, great performance and a reasonably comfortable ride.

Competitors - Honda HR-V RS and Hyundai Kona 1.6 Turbo

Review: 2020 Proton X50 - all the pros and flaws about Malaysia's most-hyped SUV! 49

While the HR-V and Kona are the X50's direct competitors, most of you will most probably cross-shop with the current crop of B-segment sedans too, since they're all similarly priced. To see how all of them perform, refer to the table below for quick links to their reviews:

2020 Proton X50 competitors' review
Car Review link
Honda HR-V Article Link
2020 Hyundai Kona Article Link
2020 Nissan Almera Article Link
2020 Honda City  Article Link

(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

Sanjay

Writer

With humble beginnings collecting diecast models and spending hours virtually tuning dream cars on the computer, his love of cars has delightfully transformed into a career. Sanjay enjoys how the same passion for cars transcends boundaries and brings people together.

Comments

Up to 20% higher than average trade-in price

2020 Proton X50 1.5T Standard

Upgrade

Add your car

Service powered by carsome

Latest Cars